I think, between Paris/Alexandros or Menelaus/Atreides, Menalaus is nobler. Why? It is because he really wants to fight fair. Also, there is a corresponding reward to whoever kills who. If Paris kills Menelaus, Helen and all the wealth would come to Paris. But if Menelaus kills Paris, likewise, all the wealth and Helen would be given to him. Also, I think Menelaus is more honorable because before his fight with Paris, he prayed to Zeus, although he kind of cursed Zeus after he got hit by a splinter saying “ O Father Zeus, such an unkind god as you there never was. You do spoil everything! I did think I had paid out that scoundrel, and here is my sword broken in my hand, and my spear missed and never touched him ”. Actually, although I think Menelaus’ more nobler, Paris is more sincere. It is because Menelaus only prayed for vengeance. And as we know Zeus, doesn’t take sides, because he is the most just among all Greek gods.
Well, according to the web, noble means baronial: impressive in appearance. That is why I have chosen Menelaus. He is more impressive and determined to kill his opponent. If you are in Menelaus’ seat you would surely be longing for vengeance. The one who kidnapped your beautiful wife is challenging you to a fight to death. From the parts which Menelaus was battling Paris, they BOTH showed nobleness because of the almost great fight they have given each other until Aphrodite butts in and brings Paris to a bed.
Today, I think I can compare Menelaus to a broken hearted man who would do anything just to have his wife/girlfriend back. A certain someone who would kill just to redeem what is rightfully his. And Paris, I can compare him to some Muslim people who marries a random person. Even a person that he/she does not even know, and it was forced to do. I do not know a certain person like Menelaus in real life but in Television, I know one. From the ‘Teleserye’ “Noah”, Judah ( played by Joem Bascon ), is the Husband of Ruth ( Jodie Sta. Maria ) and would kill anyone who tries to get her away from him. Although Gabriel ( Piolo Pascual ) is the main character here, like Paris, he still wants Jodi. I think that should be a good example to a modern day Menelaus/Paris.
And so, I end my post with a clip from the movie Troy
Score:8
ReplyDeleteAnalyzing the concept of "honor" based on a commonly accepted definition is commendable. However, it would have been better if you explored the topic further. In this manner, your reader may further understand your point.
Nonetheless, this is a good start. I am expecting more interesting discussions next time!Keep up the good work!
p.s. I like your description in your profile. Nice!